Brahma this, Brahma that...

Discussion in 'General Car Audio Discussions' started by kbog, Jul 30, 2002.

  1. kbog

    kbog Full Member

    Since I heard the Brahma (Ryno's), I have been reading tons on it. So many people love it and yet a lot of people are finding problems too.

    Dan Wiggins is saying about 3% of the sales are showing problems and under 1% are defective. I believe that.

    He is also saying that the tinsel slap is only on the 12" brahma around 48 hz and only when it is pulled back beyond 28mm which is beyond the limits of excursion. This leads me to believe that Ryno's sub is not showing slap, but rather something else which is causing vibration.

    There is NO WAY that the sub was at full excursion at the volumes it was vibrating at. They were normal listening levels when the vibration first started to occur. Ugh. This needs resolution.

    Ryno, what is the latest???
     
  2. JohnBlayz142

    JohnBlayz142 Full Member

    after talking to him, it doesn't seem like he is a very pleased customer...
     
  3. kbog

    kbog Full Member

    After hearing it, I would not be either. The noise completely ruins that fact that the sub sounds great.

    Does that make sense at all?
     
  4. DanWiggins

    DanWiggins Full Member

    Couple of things:

    1. There is quite a bit of slack in the tinsel leads. The only way to break them is to pull them tight, which happens at high excursion. There is simply no other way to pull the leads loose. Note that a single loud kick drum can result in a peak that is 2-3 times what the eye will pick up (the decay part will be much lower in amplitude, but is what is visible).

    2. Make sure you have completely eliminated box issues. I know KingJamez fought a nasty buzz issue for days before isolating it to the box.

    3. If all else fails, contact your dealer about service. If you have a problem and can't solve it, contact your dealer - they can help you (that's what you pay them for).

    Thanks,

    Dan Wiggins
    Adire Audio
     
  5. JohnBlayz142

    JohnBlayz142 Full Member

    im not tryin to say anything, but i have heard of problems with the brahma before, and it just doesn't seem appealing...from mroe than one person...

    almost makes me hesitant towards considering purchasing one
     
  6. geolemon

    geolemon Full Member

    I definitely agree with you, JohnBlayz...
    And I am sure Adire hears these concerns, I wouldn't doubt if you see the very next release of the Brahma addresses these issues publicly! ;)

    But it really is an issue that I think can be worked around, it wouldn't STOP me from buying one...
    I have thought of several ways that I might attempt to solve that sort of issue, if I encountered it, if I had one... it's not a "make it or break it"...
    Although it can be annoying for sure!

    But I think the Brahma is enough of a "super sub" at a reasonable price to still make it very worth it...

    And like Dan says, if you don't think the issue is within "normal" tolerances (or even what is acceptable to you), deal with the dealer!

    Good luck to Ryno, I will be looking forward to hearing what he finds out (as MANY people here will be looking forward to as well!)..
     
  7. kbog

    kbog Full Member

    Dan,

    It must be easy to read posts like mine and feel defensive. You believe in your product as you should. Understand I'm not trying to bash you or your products. Neither am I trying to tarnish Adire's reputation.

    I'm simply speaking honestly as I always try to do.

    The leads are not broken. They are fine. The only evidence of breakage is a small blue band just above the point where the lead is glued to the cone. This band looks to be there to hold the two leads together at the point of insertion. Part of the band is in the glue, part is not. It appears ripped apart. This does not appear to be the cause of the noise however. It might even be that way on purpose - I don't know.

    Also, we eliminated the box from the equation. The speaker makes the same noise when played free air. It is coming from the speaker. Somehow, it is probably lead slap, though I can't figure out how with that pad there. It only does it at a specific frequency though.

    Johnblayz142,

    Don't discount it yet. Underneath that rattle was a very nice sounding speaker (if you believe that). It was VERY impressive to say the least. I liked it better than the 13W7 I recently heard. If this problem is cleared up as I'm sure it will be, this driver should still be top of your list. If it is not cleared up and is a indeed a product flaw, look elsewhere. Time will tell.
     
  8. sandt38

    sandt38 Full Member

    hey fellas,

    Ive been doing some investigation of the slap and have found a couple of things thanks to the inverted install. First, when I started to play mine it had almost no slap, then it began after a couple of weeks. Being in my trunk I never really minded it as it is inaudible. With Ryans complaints though, I used the inverted install to our advantage. I feel the suspension becomes a bit more compliant after a good banging, so maybe it's time to take the gains down a tad. I took mine down about 1/2 volt. Next is the wear I am seeing on the tinsels. It seems the tinsels are slapping the spider itself, rather than the cone. I will glue some cotton to the spider today and see what effect it has on the driver slap. Also, the tinsel mounts are in a 60 degree or so bend off the back of the binding posts. I bent mine to about 80 degrees and it helped some of the slap as well. I also noticed the pad on the cone has shifted. This is due to overexcursion of the cone. The tinsels are coliding with the spider and the cone, forcing the pad toward the surround. This, I feel, is due to the suspension becoming more compliant, and should be able to be corrected by resetting gains after suspension break in occurs. I'll continue to look for remedies to the slap and let you know what I am coming up with as I go.

    Don't be discouraged Ryan. We'll work out some remedies for the problem. I'm working as hard as I can to get you taken care of by the end of this weekend. Just think of how good it really does sound, and how loud it is!!!
     
  9. sandt38

    sandt38 Full Member

    Fellas, I have a fix. I have little time right now, but I will post the fix and some pics of the fix, most likely tomorrow. I have a busy night.
     
  10. kbog

    kbog Full Member

    :headbang:

    Good news for Ryno
     
  11. FaintReality

    FaintReality Full Member

    Is this a manufacture default with all the Brahma's? I am trying to decide between the Brahma and W7 so please post the results of the fix ASAP.

    Dave
     
  12. kbog

    kbog Full Member

    Welcome Faint. Good to see (read) you.
     
  13. FaintReality

    FaintReality Full Member

    Shouldn't you be getting ready for your honeymoon? Hard to get off these forums isn't it? My girl thanks I spend too much time on the computer:rolleyes:
     
  14. sandt38

    sandt38 Full Member

    OK, no pics right now, I'll do them later. I spent alot of time looking at the way the Brahma was moving and looking for possible problems. Rhyno's displeasure sent me on a crusade:eek: . As everyone knows, I talked him into the Brahma, and I wanted to be sure he was happy. because the Brahma is in my trunk, I don't hear the slap and it doesn't bother me much. Thanks to the inverted install, and a timing light, I was able to watch her in action, and see the possible reasons for the slap. I already listed my observations with the tinsel mounts and that did quiet her down some, but the slap was still definately there. I looked the tinsels, cone and spider all over before playing it for obvious signs of wear (indicating slap) and found a couple things.

    I contacted Dan and sent him the same pics I sent to both Geo and Ryno, as well as a few more. I gave him my input, and he promptly replied with some possible solutions, so thanks to Dan for his time.

    First, the pad on the cone has obviously moved toward the surround. I felt the break in heat (because Adire doesn't cook their coils before delivery) was softening the glue and causing it to shift. Dan said that most likely it was over-excursion causing the spider and coil to collide, via the tinsels, forcing the pad down the cone. That makes sense, but I still feel it was break in heat, as there is still glue accross the whole pad. I felt adding some felt to the exposed area may help, but with Dan's point (about collision of cone/spider) I investigated further. Note... I did not add felt to the cone area, the fix seems to be elsewhere.

    The insulation on the tinsels was worn right where the outside edge of the spider would meet it, so I had obvious contact there. Read this well, this is the fix!!! I told Dan about a desire to cover the spider at the contact point. I figured some felt in that area would help as well, but Dan suggested I glue a cotton ball to the spider (I hope this doesn't void my warranty Dan :D ). I used some wound cotton and some spray glue to attatch it to the spider. The Brahma is silent. The slap is GONE. All gone. Don't use a big ball of cotton, I worry about a big ball forcing the leads into the cone. Keep it as flat as possible.

    When I set the gains to the sub initially, I heard a modest slap, and I backed off a hair. Over time (maybe 2 weeks), the slap developed, and seemed not to get better or worse after about 2 weeks. With the cotton on the spider, and the slap gone, I was able to set my gains higher. I opened it wide open and heard no distortion, or slap, or mechanical noise. I decided to use my O-scope on it to reset my gains properly. The Brahma is quiet, and quite happy now. Ryan, I really hope this helps. If not it may be a driver defect, and time to get in touch with the vendor. I buy direct from Adire myself, just to eliminate the middleman. I truely hope this helps. Please fellas, feel free to attatch this wherever you see a Brahma noise problem.

    Brahma for president AGAIN!!!
     
  15. kbog

    kbog Full Member

    Good post. Thanks fr the time and effort. Now let's see if Ryno sent the sub back already...

    Faint,

    I have to sneak out to check messages. He, He. I leave in 8 hours.
     
  16. FaintReality

    FaintReality Full Member

    Did Dan say he was gonna fix this problem, or am I gonna have to bust out the cotton once I order the Brahma?
     
  17. syntekz

    syntekz Full Member

    Cotton my friend.
     
  18. geolemon

    geolemon Full Member

    Timing light...
    Sandt, you are a freaking genius!

    I certainly commend you, in the first place, for not being one to complain about something without investigating the issue first...
    That often bugs me... it seems like too many people are just like "waaaaaaa..." too often...
    That's certainly not you, that's certainly not me!

    The difference is, I also would have watched it in action, inverted, looked it over, poked pushed and prodded...
    But I wouldn't have had the stroke of genius to break out the timing light!
    Hell, I wouldn't have been able to figure how to hook up the tach sensor... was it as simple as clamping it onto the sub lead(assuming inductive pickup)?



    Wow, you said "I used a timing light" earlier, didn't you?
    Sorry, I am still impressed with that... :D

    I wonder if Dan will be adding some sort of pad to upcoming Brahmas in this area (hint hint)...
    And good job Sandt! YOU are the one who discovered the fix to the lead slap! (applause applause)

    There's no such thing as the tooth fairy, santa claus, marty moose, the easter bunny, or over-excursion!
    Can't have too much excursion...
    It's only too much excursion when you end up with a crushed voice coil former! :D
    j/k....
     
  19. sandt38

    sandt38 Full Member

    I haven't contacted him yet on this. I saw him here earlier today, and I'm sure we'll see and hopefully hear from him tomorrow regaurding this finding. I will be surprised if it isn't addressed. Quite simply, the outside roll of the spider is all that was in contact with the tinsel. Looks like an easy problem to correct.
     
  20. sandt38

    sandt38 Full Member

    No. actually I pulled another car next to mine. all it did was slow down the movenent of cone, like a strobe effect. I don't know if the current through the speaker wire would be enough to trigger the light, so I just used a car. That is actually an old trick to fire the light on a TB injection unit to observe the feul pattern to determine if the injector is partially clogged (rather common problem in the old iron dukes causing ping).

    Thanks for the props Geo. Coming from you it is definately a compliment.